Home » Aggression » Could there be a way of reducing the persistent human phenomenon of violence toward other groups?

Could there be a way of reducing the persistent human phenomenon of violence toward other groups?

A brain scan image from the study, showing activity in the brain's reward network. (Image contributed by David Chester.)

A brain scan image from the study, showing activity in the brain’s reward network.

(Image contributed by David Chester.)

A new study led by researchers at Virginia Commonwealth University used brain imaging to explain why humans are aggressive toward rival groups.

Humans tend to form groups, which often find themselves in conflict with rival groups. But why do people show such a ready tendency to harm people in opposing groups?

new study led by researchers at Virginia Commonwealth University used functional brain imaging technology to reveal a potential answer: It increases activity in the brain’s reward network.

“At a time of deepening political divisions and global conflict, it is crucial for us to understand why people divide each other up into ‘us’ and ‘them’ and then show a profound willingness to harm ‘them,’” said corresponding author David Chester, Ph.D., an associate professor in the Department of Psychology in the College of Humanities and Sciences. “Our findings advance this understanding by suggesting that harming outgroup members is a relatively rewarding experience.”

The researchers had 35 male college students complete a competitive, aggressive task against either a student from their university or from what they were told was a rival university. In reality, participants unknowingly played against a computer program, and no real people were harmed.

They found that participants who were more aggressive against outgroup members (students from a rival university) versus ingroup members (students from their own university) exhibited greater activity in core regions of the brain’s reward circuit — the nucleus accumbens and ventromedial prefrontal cortex — while they decided how aggressive to be.

Both before and after outgroup exclusion, aggression toward outgroup members was positively associated with activity in the ventral striatum during decisions about how aggressive to be toward their outgroup opponent. Aggression toward outgroup members was also linked to greater post-exclusion activity in the rostral and dorsal medial prefrontal cortex during provocation from their outgroup opponent. These altered patterns of brain activity suggest that frontostriatal mechanisms may play a significant role in motivating aggression toward outgroup members.

The findings suggest that harming outgroup members is especially rewarding and associated with the experience of positive emotions. Such psychological reinforcement mechanisms may help explain why humans seem so prone to intergroup conflict, Chester said.

“This finding helps to balance the narrative about the psychological processes that underlie aggression against outgroup members, which typically emphasizes negative emotional states such as anger and fear,” Chester said. “This study showed that positive emotions may play a role in motivating intergroup aggression, which suggests many new directions for future research on this topic and informs potential interventions that seek to reduce group conflict.”

The findings raise the possibility that one day treatments that disrupt the reward of intergroup aggression might help to reduce the costly and persistent human phenomenon of violence toward other groups, Chester said.

Chester is director of the Social Psychology and Neuroscience Lab at VCU, which seeks to understand why people try to harm one another. In the past, the lab has focused on conflicts between two individuals, and sought to remove any element of group membership, identity or partisanship in carefully controlled experiments. This new study, however, is the lab’s first foray into exploring the neural correlates of intergroup aggression.

“These new findings fit nicely with our previous research, which has repeatedly implicated the brain’s reward circuitry (i.e., the nucleus accumbens and ventromedial prefrontal cortex) in promoting aggressive acts,” he said. “We have advanced this line of investigation by showing that such reward activity during aggression exerts even more of an effect in an intergroup context than in a nongroup context.”

While the researchers weren’t surprised by the new findings, they were surprised to find such results even when experimenting with a weak group rivalry.

“Many groups have ancient histories of deep hatred of one another and our use of rival universities didn’t even come close to capturing what many truly problematic intergroup conflicts look like around the world,” Chester said. “We chose such a mild intergroup rivalry for several reasons, a major one being that invoking a deeply rooted intergroup conflict might cause our participants undue distress. But it was still surprising to see such clear results despite our use of a relatively minor intergroup rivalry. I surmise that our observed effect would be even stronger in the context of intergroup conflict between two groups that deeply hate each other.”

The area of the brain implicated in the study is not only associated with reward, it is also involved in other psychological processes such as learning, motivation and identity. While Chester said it is possible that the brain activity was not reflecting the subjective experience of pleasure, decades of brain research suggests that area’s core functions are reliably reward-linked to the point where the researchers felt comfortable making the inference, Chester said. More research would be needed to definitely say that reward is the “culprit underlying intergroup conflict,” he said.


Original Article: Us versus them: Harming the ‘outgroup’ is linked to elevated activity in the brain’s reward circuitry

More from: Virginia Commonwealth University 


The Latest on: Intergroup conflict

  • Mongoose intergroup warfare is very similar to human conflicts
    on March 27, 2023 at 7:31 am

    Researchers suggest the African species are a good model to study the evolution of altruism and other cooperative behaviors, as well as our propensity for violence ...

  • Ending conflict of Boomers vs Strawberry Generations
    on March 26, 2023 at 5:34 am

    Intergenerational conflict is a classical issue which has been persisting since long ago. In the current era, there are claims which put different ...

  • Threat Rhetoric: Understanding the language used to stoke violence by those who want to divide society
    on March 16, 2023 at 3:00 am

    As a social psychologist who studies dangerous speech and disinformation, I think it’s important for citizens, legislators and law enforcement alike to understand that language can provoke violence ...

  • Professor Shelley McKeown Jones
    on August 25, 2022 at 1:33 am

    I am a social psychologist whose research focuses broadly on understanding how to improve intergroup relations in diverse and conflict settings using quantitative methods. I am particularly interested ...

  • Political Psychology: Inequality & Intergroup Relations
    on February 28, 2022 at 2:46 am

    The course will explore the psychosocial processes underpinning prejudice and discrimination, and consider how they manifest in debates around migration, diversity, social mobility, and intergroup ...

  • CIP 30 Multi/Interdisciplinary Studies
    on November 16, 2021 at 3:25 pm

    A program that derives from two or more distinct programs and that is integrated around a unifying theme or topic that cannot be subsumed under a single discipline or occupational field. 30.0001 ...

  • An Intergroup Theory of Social Hierarchy and Oppression
    on July 2, 2021 at 2:23 am

    This book suggests that the major forms in intergroup conflict, such as racism, classism and patriarchy, are essentially derived from the human predisposition to form and maintain hierarchical and ...

  • Political Psychology: Inequality & Intergroup Relations
    on September 14, 2020 at 5:12 am

    It then applies these lenses to the understanding of contemporary issues concerning intergroup inequality. We will explore the psychosocial processes underpinning racism and prejudice, and will ask ...

  • Who were the primary targets of non-state armed group attacks in 2019?
    on May 13, 2020 at 10:38 pm

    Inter-group conflict was the reason for 1,538 attacks in 2019. Which local groups are fighting against each other? How much is inter-group conflict related each group's militant propaganda?

  • Organizational Conflict Theory
    on July 20, 2018 at 7:02 am

    Similar to role conflict, inter-group conflict usually occurs because of the roles and functions of teams and departments. Both are just trying to do their jobs, but somehow run up against each other.

via Bing News

The Latest on: Intergroup conflict

[google_news title=”” keyword=”intergroup conflict” num_posts=”10″ blurb_length=”0″ show_thumb=”left”]

via Google News